LUKE KEHOE
  • Home
  • Fixed
    • Exploring the Edge and the Future of a Decentralised Internet
    • Messing with the National Broadband Plan is a perilous precedent for Ireland
    • How Fibre is shaping 5G
    • Examining the viability of FWA in the 5G Era
    • The Changing Face of Broadband in Ireland
    • Dismantling the Optics of a National Broadband Plan fraught with trouble
    • Ireland's Gigabit Society is now within an arm's reach
    • The Merits of a Hybrid Broadband Network
    • Fibre: The Electricity of Tomorrow
    • The National Broadband Plan: Needlessly corrupted by Politics
    • Investigating the alternatives to Fibre Broadband in Ireland
    • Virgin Media: The Company that changed how we think about Broadband in Ireland
    • The Evolution of Quad-Play Services
    • An Analysis of Net Neutrality in Ireland: Why we are Particularly Vulnerable to its Eradication
    • The Best Mobile Broadband Plans in Ireland
    • eir: Few Companies have this much Potential
    • The National Broadband Plan: A Dream marred by Mistakes
    • How SIRO is revolutionising Ireland
    • The Best Fibre Broadband Only Plans
  • Mobile
    • Analysis: Vodafone goes unlimited in Ireland
    • A Breath of Fresh Eir
    • Understanding VoLTE: The Voice of Tomorrow
    • Your Technical Guide to WiFi Calling in Ireland.
    • Mapping Ireland and Europe's path to 5G
    • 5G and the Divide Divide haunting Ireland
    • Busting three myths thwarting the IoT
    • The MVNO model is ripe for disruption
    • Pest Pulse is using the IoT to tackle an old problem in a new way
    • The trends that will shape Ireland's Mobile Market in 2019
    • Mobile Coverage and Ireland: Not a Match
    • An Interview with the man building Ireland's largest IoT Network: Will Ferguson
    • The State of the IoT in Ireland
    • The Struggle to Monetise Data
    • In Ireland, Huawei finds a home with Three and eir, rebelling against "Security Concerns"
    • Revealed: The Irish Network with the Best 4G Coverage 2018
    • How are we tackling Coverage Black Spots in Ireland?
    • Breaking Down ComReg's latest Report on the Irish Mobile Market
    • The Shift from Growth to Retention in the Irish Telecoms Market
    • Five Challenges that the IoT is facing
    • Why ComReg is Vital for a Successful Telecoms Industry in Ireland
    • Tesco Mobile passes 400,000 Customers and adds 4G
    • How our Mobile Providers are facilitating surging Data Traffic
    • Eight Industries that are being transformed by Sigfox
    • Vodafone Review: The Best Network in Ireland keeps getting Better
    • Why will 5G be faster than 4G?
    • Is Xavier Niel on the verge of shaking up the Irish Mobile Market with Eir
    • Eir overhauls its mobile plans, giving customers more data than ever
    • NB-IoT Explained: The Technology that Vodafone hopes will connect everything
    • The MVNO Flop: Why Ireland's MVNOs have failed to make an impact
    • Explained: Why Telecoms and Media Giants are Merging
    • The Power of Sigfox: Pioneering the IoT Revolution
    • Vodafone Ireland launches "V by Vodafone", bringing the Internet of Things to the masses
    • The IoT Revolution: Connecting Everything
    • The Unlimited Delusion: When Unlimited means Limited
    • The Best Mobile Plans for your Business
    • The Best Bill Pay Plans in Ireland
    • The Best Pay as you go Plans in Ireland
    • Was the Three-O2 Merger a Mistake?
    • The State of Irish Mobile Networks: Summer 2018
    • Vodafone killed Cherry Points: A Mistake?
    • Here's how 5G will transform Ireland
    • Three just stormed past Eir
    • An analysis of Ireland's big three Mobile Networks
    • How Cheap can our Mobile Plans Get?
    • Net Neutrality: More than the Internet is at stake
    • Here's why Vodafone's pay as you go plans are the best out there.
    • iD Mobile's Demise is hardly a surprise
    • The Battle for 5G Supremacy
    • Unlimited Data is only as good as the Network it's on.
  • Reviews
    • eir Mobile Review: Not the Network to choose in 2018
    • Invoxia GPS Tracker Review: Elegance boasts Phenomenal Battery Life
    • Three Review: The Best Value Network in Ireland
    • Sennheiser AMBEO Smart Headset Review:
    • Vodafone TV Review: Redefining what we think of TV
    • Vodafone Mobile Broadband Review: Connecting the Disconnected
    • 3Plus Review: The Best Loyalty Program Out There
    • 3 Sim Only Review: World-Class Value
    • Tesco Mobile Review: The Best network for the Frugal
    • Three Review: All you can Eat Buffering
    • Vodafone Review: The Network to Beat
    • Meteor Review: Excellence Exemplified
    • Should Virgin Media be your next Mobile Network?
    • Samsung Galaxy S8: The Pinnacle of Smartphone Advancement
    • Huawei P10: The Best phone people don't know about
    • Vodafone Smart Platinum 7.
    • Vodafone Smart Prime 7.

Was The Three-O2 Merger a Mistake?

There are now only three mobile networks in Ireland, has that hindered competition?
Picture
Published 07/07/18
Recently, reports have emerged suggesting that the takeover of Telefónica's O2 in Ireland by Three was a mistake on behalf of European competition authorities. In a vacuum, that would be true. Since the consolidation of the two networks, prices have risen across virtually all pay as you go and bill pay plans. However, that's not the full story because a mobile network is more than just the price of its plans.

The merger of Three and O2 has brought significantly more competition to Ireland's largest mobile network, Vodafone. Big Red ruled the Irish market by quite a significant margin for many years. Now, Three's customer base is similar in size to that of Vodafone's. The merger has compelled Vodafone to overhaul its dated plans and offer customers more data than ever before without raising prices. It's also possible that Vodafone's network investment in Ireland may have been less significant if the company knew the merger would be blocked. It's no wonder Vodafone made efforts to block the merger.

Three now has over two million customers, a full one million customers more than that of Eir. The merger meant that Three leapfrogged Eir, pushing the company to streamline its mobile offering. Since the merger, increased competition has forced Eir to embark on a rebranding saga, abolishing Meteor Mobile and changing the name to Eir. The death of Meteor can be attributed, in some way, to the rise of Three. Eir, like Vodafone, has also had to be nicer to its customers. The network now provides significantly more data across all of its plans and prices remain steady.
Picture

Investing in a brighter future

Following the merger, Three's combined network with O2 was a complete mess. O2 neglected its customers and didn't launch a 4G network. Three's own network was limited in coverage. When O2 customers were suddenly given access to unlimited data, the networks collapsed. There were months of outages and capacity shortages. If you were a Three or O2 customer, it was very unpleasant and outright unfair. At the same time, Vodafone pushed ahead with Project Spring, delivering a state of the art network to its customers. For quite a while, Vodafone's network was years ahead of Three.​
Picture
Three years later, Three's network is no longer the mess it once was. Here is the key point I want to make, the merger has allowed Three to invest significantly more money in the network. With almost three times the number of customers than previously, it gives Three the opportunity to receive more money from Hutchinson.  This increased investment benefits everyone in Ireland, not just Three customers.

"The Big Upgrade Programme", a €350 million network upgrade programme, has brought Three's network out of the stone age and flying into the 21st century. Three customers now enjoy a level of service that would be impossible had the merger not taken place. This is thanks in part to the spectrum Three received when it bought O2. Three has the most amount of 4G spectrum of any network in Ireland, that is a big deal. Again, this directly benefits the customer and allows Three to continue offering unlimited data to its customers.

Then there is also the advantage of having more cell sites to choose from. A major part of the "Big Upgrade" programme has been to overhaul the radio access network and the core network. The merger allows Three to essentially choose the best cell sites to serve its customers. Many O2 cell towers have now been decommissioned, creating synergies for Three.

Three's network sure isn't perfect, its still behind Vodafone in virtually every aspect. But the margins between the networks are shrinking, rapidly. The network now has over 900 4G+ sites providing maximum speeds of 400Mbps. I've managed to obtain some more precise coverage data from Three themselves. Three provides over 94% 4G population coverage in Ireland. Three now delivers 94% 4G coverage across Donegal. Three now delivers 93% 4G coverage across Carlow. Three now delivers 99% 4G coverage across Kilkenny. Three now delivers 96% 4G coverage across Louth. Three now delivers 95% 4G coverage across Monaghan.

Vodafone's efforts to block the merger were based upon the fear of Three owning too much spectrum. The EU ensured Three set aside up to 30% of its spectrum for two new MVNO's with the opportunity for them to build out their own network in the future. However, Vodafone claimed that it would be highly unlikely for these MVNO's to ever build out their own network. Guess what, Vodafone was right. One MVNO is no longer and it is highly unlikely that Virgin Mobile will develop its own mobile network. Three now regains control of the 15% spectrum that iD Mobile held, tightening its control of spectrum provided by ComReg.​


To conclude, the merger has allowed Three to invest in a network that will support its customer's needs for the near future, taking advantage of new spectrum and operating more cell sites than ever before.​
For a more detailed analysis of Three's network, see this article.
Picture

More Data than ever, Cheaper than ever

Looking at the Irish Mobile market today compared to the one before the merger, a few things are very clear. Customers now enjoy more data than ever, at cheaper prices than ever. Three has had a major influence in this, the network has offered all you can eat data as its unique selling point for quite a while now and people love it. Unfortunately, it is very difficult to determine if increased data allowances are a result of increased competition or the ever-evolving trend of larger data allowances. You see, smartphone screens have gotten larger over time and can now stream 4K content which demands more data.

To gain a greater insight into this matter, we need to look to other countries. In this case, Irish data allowances are well above the European average and plan prices are well below the average. This is a telling sign that competition has yielded great benefits for Irish consumers. Comparing the fixed broadband market with Europe, it's clear that ComReg has failed to maintain competition, Irish consumers are amongst the highest spenders on fixed broadband on the continent. We can thank Eir's monopoly for this.

The death of iD Mobile, a Mobile Virtual Network Operator(MVNO), set up by Dixons Carphone Warehouse, also depicts a highly competitive Irish mobile market. iD Mobile made efforts to attract customers by offering large data bundles and flexible plans, but it wasn't enough for customers to abandon their network. iD Mobile went the way of the dinosaur in less than three years, proving a mobile network is more than just the sum of its plans. In fact, Three even capitalised on the death of iD Mobile, bombarding iD Mobile customers with flashy offers to attract them to Three.

Virgin Mobile, set up in 2015 under the conditions of the merger, has grown steadily and now has a 1% share in the Irish mobile market. The MVNO has offered incredibly inexpensive plans for as little as €5 a month in a desperate effort to attract customers. I suspect the average revenue per user on Virgin Mobile to be very low. In short, both MVNO's have had a minuscule impact on the Irish mobile market. The terms of the merger have failed miserably in
this aspect. However, competition is still very healthy, the death of iD Mobile is a prime example of this.
Picture

ComReg's motives are complex

ComReg recently released the results of a study it conducted on the effects of the merger on the Irish mobile market. The results paint a dismal picture for Three customers in terms of pricing. As mentioned already, ComReg has found all of Three's customers have had to endure price hikes. To put this into context, the merger has hurt longtime Three customers. However, the merger has benefitted former O2 customers who now have access to much larger data allowances for similar prices.

Had ComReg got the ultimate say in the merger, it wouldn't have occurred. The watchdog raised serious concerns with European competition authorities at the time, fearing it would hurt competition. In my view, that outcome would have been negative for many Irish consumers. A failed merger would have potentially allowed Vodafone to create a monopoly, thwarting competition and hurting consumers. The failure of O2 to roll out a 4G network would have exacerbated things and Three's existence in Ireland would be uncertain.

​It should also be mentioned that ComReg would have benefitted from a failed merger. The watchdog would have received more revenue in spectrum auctions due to an extra bidder and also in a myriad of other areas. It could be concluded that ComReg's motivations to block the merger may not have been based purely on ensuring competition in the Irish mobile market.

​Competition remains healthy in the Irish mobile market. It's now ComReg's job to prevent the repeat of the stagnant broadband market. Eir's monopoly in the broadband market has hurt everyone, don't let another monopoly come to power.​
The State of Mobile Networks: Summer 2018
Picture
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Fixed
    • Exploring the Edge and the Future of a Decentralised Internet
    • Messing with the National Broadband Plan is a perilous precedent for Ireland
    • How Fibre is shaping 5G
    • Examining the viability of FWA in the 5G Era
    • The Changing Face of Broadband in Ireland
    • Dismantling the Optics of a National Broadband Plan fraught with trouble
    • Ireland's Gigabit Society is now within an arm's reach
    • The Merits of a Hybrid Broadband Network
    • Fibre: The Electricity of Tomorrow
    • The National Broadband Plan: Needlessly corrupted by Politics
    • Investigating the alternatives to Fibre Broadband in Ireland
    • Virgin Media: The Company that changed how we think about Broadband in Ireland
    • The Evolution of Quad-Play Services
    • An Analysis of Net Neutrality in Ireland: Why we are Particularly Vulnerable to its Eradication
    • The Best Mobile Broadband Plans in Ireland
    • eir: Few Companies have this much Potential
    • The National Broadband Plan: A Dream marred by Mistakes
    • How SIRO is revolutionising Ireland
    • The Best Fibre Broadband Only Plans
  • Mobile
    • Analysis: Vodafone goes unlimited in Ireland
    • A Breath of Fresh Eir
    • Understanding VoLTE: The Voice of Tomorrow
    • Your Technical Guide to WiFi Calling in Ireland.
    • Mapping Ireland and Europe's path to 5G
    • 5G and the Divide Divide haunting Ireland
    • Busting three myths thwarting the IoT
    • The MVNO model is ripe for disruption
    • Pest Pulse is using the IoT to tackle an old problem in a new way
    • The trends that will shape Ireland's Mobile Market in 2019
    • Mobile Coverage and Ireland: Not a Match
    • An Interview with the man building Ireland's largest IoT Network: Will Ferguson
    • The State of the IoT in Ireland
    • The Struggle to Monetise Data
    • In Ireland, Huawei finds a home with Three and eir, rebelling against "Security Concerns"
    • Revealed: The Irish Network with the Best 4G Coverage 2018
    • How are we tackling Coverage Black Spots in Ireland?
    • Breaking Down ComReg's latest Report on the Irish Mobile Market
    • The Shift from Growth to Retention in the Irish Telecoms Market
    • Five Challenges that the IoT is facing
    • Why ComReg is Vital for a Successful Telecoms Industry in Ireland
    • Tesco Mobile passes 400,000 Customers and adds 4G
    • How our Mobile Providers are facilitating surging Data Traffic
    • Eight Industries that are being transformed by Sigfox
    • Vodafone Review: The Best Network in Ireland keeps getting Better
    • Why will 5G be faster than 4G?
    • Is Xavier Niel on the verge of shaking up the Irish Mobile Market with Eir
    • Eir overhauls its mobile plans, giving customers more data than ever
    • NB-IoT Explained: The Technology that Vodafone hopes will connect everything
    • The MVNO Flop: Why Ireland's MVNOs have failed to make an impact
    • Explained: Why Telecoms and Media Giants are Merging
    • The Power of Sigfox: Pioneering the IoT Revolution
    • Vodafone Ireland launches "V by Vodafone", bringing the Internet of Things to the masses
    • The IoT Revolution: Connecting Everything
    • The Unlimited Delusion: When Unlimited means Limited
    • The Best Mobile Plans for your Business
    • The Best Bill Pay Plans in Ireland
    • The Best Pay as you go Plans in Ireland
    • Was the Three-O2 Merger a Mistake?
    • The State of Irish Mobile Networks: Summer 2018
    • Vodafone killed Cherry Points: A Mistake?
    • Here's how 5G will transform Ireland
    • Three just stormed past Eir
    • An analysis of Ireland's big three Mobile Networks
    • How Cheap can our Mobile Plans Get?
    • Net Neutrality: More than the Internet is at stake
    • Here's why Vodafone's pay as you go plans are the best out there.
    • iD Mobile's Demise is hardly a surprise
    • The Battle for 5G Supremacy
    • Unlimited Data is only as good as the Network it's on.
  • Reviews
    • eir Mobile Review: Not the Network to choose in 2018
    • Invoxia GPS Tracker Review: Elegance boasts Phenomenal Battery Life
    • Three Review: The Best Value Network in Ireland
    • Sennheiser AMBEO Smart Headset Review:
    • Vodafone TV Review: Redefining what we think of TV
    • Vodafone Mobile Broadband Review: Connecting the Disconnected
    • 3Plus Review: The Best Loyalty Program Out There
    • 3 Sim Only Review: World-Class Value
    • Tesco Mobile Review: The Best network for the Frugal
    • Three Review: All you can Eat Buffering
    • Vodafone Review: The Network to Beat
    • Meteor Review: Excellence Exemplified
    • Should Virgin Media be your next Mobile Network?
    • Samsung Galaxy S8: The Pinnacle of Smartphone Advancement
    • Huawei P10: The Best phone people don't know about
    • Vodafone Smart Platinum 7.
    • Vodafone Smart Prime 7.