LUKE KEHOE
  • Home
  • Fixed
    • Exploring the Edge and the Future of a Decentralised Internet
    • Messing with the National Broadband Plan is a perilous precedent for Ireland
    • How Fibre is shaping 5G
    • Examining the viability of FWA in the 5G Era
    • The Changing Face of Broadband in Ireland
    • Dismantling the Optics of a National Broadband Plan fraught with trouble
    • Ireland's Gigabit Society is now within an arm's reach
    • The Merits of a Hybrid Broadband Network
    • Fibre: The Electricity of Tomorrow
    • The National Broadband Plan: Needlessly corrupted by Politics
    • Investigating the alternatives to Fibre Broadband in Ireland
    • Virgin Media: The Company that changed how we think about Broadband in Ireland
    • The Evolution of Quad-Play Services
    • An Analysis of Net Neutrality in Ireland: Why we are Particularly Vulnerable to its Eradication
    • The Best Mobile Broadband Plans in Ireland
    • eir: Few Companies have this much Potential
    • The National Broadband Plan: A Dream marred by Mistakes
    • How SIRO is revolutionising Ireland
    • The Best Fibre Broadband Only Plans
  • Mobile
    • Analysis: Vodafone goes unlimited in Ireland
    • A Breath of Fresh Eir
    • Understanding VoLTE: The Voice of Tomorrow
    • Your Technical Guide to WiFi Calling in Ireland.
    • Mapping Ireland and Europe's path to 5G
    • 5G and the Divide Divide haunting Ireland
    • Busting three myths thwarting the IoT
    • The MVNO model is ripe for disruption
    • Pest Pulse is using the IoT to tackle an old problem in a new way
    • The trends that will shape Ireland's Mobile Market in 2019
    • Mobile Coverage and Ireland: Not a Match
    • An Interview with the man building Ireland's largest IoT Network: Will Ferguson
    • The State of the IoT in Ireland
    • The Struggle to Monetise Data
    • In Ireland, Huawei finds a home with Three and eir, rebelling against "Security Concerns"
    • Revealed: The Irish Network with the Best 4G Coverage 2018
    • How are we tackling Coverage Black Spots in Ireland?
    • Breaking Down ComReg's latest Report on the Irish Mobile Market
    • The Shift from Growth to Retention in the Irish Telecoms Market
    • Five Challenges that the IoT is facing
    • Why ComReg is Vital for a Successful Telecoms Industry in Ireland
    • Tesco Mobile passes 400,000 Customers and adds 4G
    • How our Mobile Providers are facilitating surging Data Traffic
    • Eight Industries that are being transformed by Sigfox
    • Vodafone Review: The Best Network in Ireland keeps getting Better
    • Why will 5G be faster than 4G?
    • Is Xavier Niel on the verge of shaking up the Irish Mobile Market with Eir
    • Eir overhauls its mobile plans, giving customers more data than ever
    • NB-IoT Explained: The Technology that Vodafone hopes will connect everything
    • The MVNO Flop: Why Ireland's MVNOs have failed to make an impact
    • Explained: Why Telecoms and Media Giants are Merging
    • The Power of Sigfox: Pioneering the IoT Revolution
    • Vodafone Ireland launches "V by Vodafone", bringing the Internet of Things to the masses
    • The IoT Revolution: Connecting Everything
    • The Unlimited Delusion: When Unlimited means Limited
    • The Best Mobile Plans for your Business
    • The Best Bill Pay Plans in Ireland
    • The Best Pay as you go Plans in Ireland
    • Was the Three-O2 Merger a Mistake?
    • The State of Irish Mobile Networks: Summer 2018
    • Vodafone killed Cherry Points: A Mistake?
    • Here's how 5G will transform Ireland
    • Three just stormed past Eir
    • An analysis of Ireland's big three Mobile Networks
    • How Cheap can our Mobile Plans Get?
    • Net Neutrality: More than the Internet is at stake
    • Here's why Vodafone's pay as you go plans are the best out there.
    • iD Mobile's Demise is hardly a surprise
    • The Battle for 5G Supremacy
    • Unlimited Data is only as good as the Network it's on.
  • Reviews
    • eir Mobile Review: Not the Network to choose in 2018
    • Invoxia GPS Tracker Review: Elegance boasts Phenomenal Battery Life
    • Three Review: The Best Value Network in Ireland
    • Sennheiser AMBEO Smart Headset Review:
    • Vodafone TV Review: Redefining what we think of TV
    • Vodafone Mobile Broadband Review: Connecting the Disconnected
    • 3Plus Review: The Best Loyalty Program Out There
    • 3 Sim Only Review: World-Class Value
    • Tesco Mobile Review: The Best network for the Frugal
    • Three Review: All you can Eat Buffering
    • Vodafone Review: The Network to Beat
    • Meteor Review: Excellence Exemplified
    • Should Virgin Media be your next Mobile Network?
    • Samsung Galaxy S8: The Pinnacle of Smartphone Advancement
    • Huawei P10: The Best phone people don't know about
    • Vodafone Smart Platinum 7.
    • Vodafone Smart Prime 7.

Published 23/07/2017
Special Edition Editorial

Net Neutrality:
​
Just because the internet is open today doesn't mean it will be open tomorrow

Picture

What is Net Neutrality?

Net Neutrality is a controversial topic, it highlights the divide between big corporations and their paying customers. It's peculiar because the very people who provide access to the internet intend to destroy it. The battle has gained substantial attraction in the United States where internet service providers and mobile networks have decided to abuse the very idea of the internet, an open interconnected and uncensored network which provides millions of petabytes of information at your fingertips. The basic idea of Net Neutrality is that Internet service providers should enable access to all content and applications regardless of the source, and without favouring or blocking particular services or websites. This concept says that services, for example Netflix, are to be available on every internet service provider or mobile network and are to be treated equally. Net Neutrality ensures that the internet remains an open and unbiased portal to information and prevents services from being blocked or throttled by an internet service provider or mobile network.
Picture

Without Net Neutrality, the internet would be like Cable TV

We've all heard of companies such as Sky which provide cherry-picked channels and programs for your television. Sky, like many other Cable TV services, forces you to watch what they provide you with. It's a broken way of delivering content to your television that allows companies to maximise profits. The Cable TV industry has been looked down upon in most countries because of its lack of choice and high price. Unlike the Internet, you pay to use the service, a service that is controlled by a single company. Cable TV isn't an open and unbiased service, it's actually a walled garden forcing you to make decisions from limited options controlled by a company. Just take a look at some of Sky's TV packages in Ireland at the moment, you have to pay to get 'access' to a limited range of channels, fork out more for HD content and fork out even more for content such as sports and movies. These types of services end up costing you a ludicrous amount of money and you arent even allowed watch what you want. This is the reason why millions of people have been 'cutting the cord' by canceling their Cable TV service and signing up for cheaper and better alternatives such as Netflix and Amazon Video. Cable TV is the pynical example of what the internet would look like without net neutrality.

Internet service providers and mobile networks would take advantage of their own service by charging both customers who pay to access the internet and services such as Netflix and Facebook to gain access to the Internet service provider's customers. Think of the services you use on your computer or phone at the moment, almost all require internet access to function. You could be forced to pay for access to social services such as Snapchat and Instagram or to pay for access to news outlets like CNN or Sky News. Internet service providers could create their own unrestricted services to run on their own infrastructure, potentially eliminating their competitors. For example, Eir could create their own unrestricted version of YouTube and charge customers extra to access YouTube. This would wreck havoc on smaller services and businesses who don't have the money or power to pay internet service providers for access to their customers.
Picture

Throttle, Throttle, Throttle

Throttling, the infamous act of intentionally slowing one's internet service isn't a new technique in Ireland. All the large  Irish telecoms companies throttle their customers for many varying reasons. Three, Eir, Virgin Media and recently Vodafone have decided to punish their customers who exceed their monthly allowance of data. It's a clever but annoying technique to curb high data usage by certain customers. Three is notorious for throttling its customers because of their 'All you can Eat Data' plans. The plans aren't really unlimited so when you exceed 60GB of data usage in a 28 day period Three throttles your data in congested areas. This means that where you would normally get 60Mbps on 4G, you now get a measly 0.1Mbps making it impossible to stream video. This type of throttling, while sneaky, is legal since it is stated in the terms and conditions of your plan. Mobile networks also claim that this type of throttling is necessary to minimise congestion on the network by preventing a small number of heavy data users adversely affecting others data experience.

However, in some countries such as the United States more devious tactics are being used by mobile networks and internet service providers which clearly violate Net Neutrality laws. Verizon, the largest mobile network in the United States, has admitted it secretly throttled Netflix and YouTube streams after customers complained of long buffering times. Verizon has been found to throttle 4G speeds to as little as 1Mbps for YouTube and Netflix streams. Netflix and YouTube now account for over 50% of download traffic on mobile networks globally, a staggering portion that has frightened some mobile networks like Verizon. Things get worse when you understand that Verizon's own version of Netflix, Go90, is prioritised during peak hours. This means Verizon is prioritising its own service over others and throws the concept of Net Neutrality out the window.

This type of throttling is illegal in most countries, including the United States and Verizon is facing massive fines for its actions. But that's changing, the FCC or Federal Communications Commission is the equivalent of ComReg in Ireland and wants to abolish Net Neutrality. In other words, the American telecoms watchdog believes the telecoms industry should govern itself. If companies such as Verizon are already throttling customers when it is illegal, what will they do when it becomes legal. It could evolve into a catastrophic, irreversible disaster that would hinder competition and stifle innovation.
Picture

Is Ireland Vulnerable?

As I've already explained, telecom companies in Ireland are already throttling their customers. Services such as Sky, Eir  TV and Vodafone TV already exist and offer limited, walled garden experiences for a high price. Net Neutrality has received significantly less news attention in Ireland compared to other countries and that should worry you because Ireland is particularly vulnerable to a limited, restricted internet. With three mobile networks, Ireland has one less network than the global average. The same is true for broadband, Eir holds a monopoly, having the only broadband network in most areas. This is worrying because with less players and less competition, it limits the amount of options people have when picking their network or broadband provider. It's even more worrisome when we consider two of the mobile networks are also two of the broadband and cable tv players.

Thankfully, we haven't seen too many breaches of Net Neutrality in Ireland as of yet. Vodafone and Eir, the largest communications providers in Ireland are following Net Neutrality concepts at the moment. Meteor, Ireland's third largest mobile network and a subsidiary of Eir, has been accused of breaching Net Neutrality rules by zero-rating some social media services such as Instagram, Twitter, Snapchat and Facebook. This means that Meteor customers can use these services as much as they want without eating into their data allowances. However this seemingly beneficial addition to Meteor's plans harms smaller services and even some big ones which are not zero-rated such as Netflix. I also have to call out Vodafone for zero-rating it's own TV service on its mobile plans. Like Meteor's zero-rating service, Vodafone's zero-rating of it's own Vodafone TV service is beneficial to the customer but may harm smaller services as people try to limit their data usage and use Vodafone's own service instead.

Unfortunately, no major mobile network or internet service provider has openly advocated for Net Neutrality in Ireland. That includes Three, Vodafone and Eir who have all remained silent on the matter to date.
Picture

The more a company grows, the less it cares about Net Neutrality

Successful companies eventually stop caring about the open internet. Netflix is a perfect example of this. Two years ago the company was a huge advocate for Net Neutrality, producing charts and advertisements, paying lobbyists and warning of the dangers to come if Net Neutrality was ignored. However, Netflix's CEO Reed Hastings recently said the company is less worried about Net Neutrality than it was before and that smaller companies could carry the water. This is particularly disturbing because Netflix wouldn't be thriving without Net Neutrality.

Big companies such as Microsoft, Google and Amazon have spent millions lobbying for Net Neutrality. Thats a good thing because these companies wouldn't exist without it. Google and Amazon arguably have the most to lose if internet service providers ignore Net Neutrality. Amazon could be forced to pay companies like Eir for an internet fast lane or could be blocked altogether if a rival such as eBay pays more for access to the internet service provider's customers. It could wreck havoc on Google if competitors such as Microsoft's Bing pay more for no throttling and faster web searches.

The companies providing the internet are destroying the internet

An internet without Net Neutrality isn't an internet , it's an intranet. It's a walled garden like current Cable TV services such as Sky. There's no choice and no openness. Customers will be charged to access different services, companies who don't pay up will see their internet traffic collapse and smaller companies will be hurt most. An internet without Net Neutrality would stifle innovation, it would prevent advancement and would be the biggest disaster of our time. The internet was built to provide information to billions of people and to spread knowledge all across the globe. The internet has facilitated the growth of revolutionary products such as the smartphone and computer. It's more than just entertainment services and social media that's at stake, millions of jobs are at stake too. Let's just hope internet service providers don't become a victim of their own success. Lets hope the very people who provide the internet don't destroy the internet.
Picture
Vodafone Review
Picture
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Fixed
    • Exploring the Edge and the Future of a Decentralised Internet
    • Messing with the National Broadband Plan is a perilous precedent for Ireland
    • How Fibre is shaping 5G
    • Examining the viability of FWA in the 5G Era
    • The Changing Face of Broadband in Ireland
    • Dismantling the Optics of a National Broadband Plan fraught with trouble
    • Ireland's Gigabit Society is now within an arm's reach
    • The Merits of a Hybrid Broadband Network
    • Fibre: The Electricity of Tomorrow
    • The National Broadband Plan: Needlessly corrupted by Politics
    • Investigating the alternatives to Fibre Broadband in Ireland
    • Virgin Media: The Company that changed how we think about Broadband in Ireland
    • The Evolution of Quad-Play Services
    • An Analysis of Net Neutrality in Ireland: Why we are Particularly Vulnerable to its Eradication
    • The Best Mobile Broadband Plans in Ireland
    • eir: Few Companies have this much Potential
    • The National Broadband Plan: A Dream marred by Mistakes
    • How SIRO is revolutionising Ireland
    • The Best Fibre Broadband Only Plans
  • Mobile
    • Analysis: Vodafone goes unlimited in Ireland
    • A Breath of Fresh Eir
    • Understanding VoLTE: The Voice of Tomorrow
    • Your Technical Guide to WiFi Calling in Ireland.
    • Mapping Ireland and Europe's path to 5G
    • 5G and the Divide Divide haunting Ireland
    • Busting three myths thwarting the IoT
    • The MVNO model is ripe for disruption
    • Pest Pulse is using the IoT to tackle an old problem in a new way
    • The trends that will shape Ireland's Mobile Market in 2019
    • Mobile Coverage and Ireland: Not a Match
    • An Interview with the man building Ireland's largest IoT Network: Will Ferguson
    • The State of the IoT in Ireland
    • The Struggle to Monetise Data
    • In Ireland, Huawei finds a home with Three and eir, rebelling against "Security Concerns"
    • Revealed: The Irish Network with the Best 4G Coverage 2018
    • How are we tackling Coverage Black Spots in Ireland?
    • Breaking Down ComReg's latest Report on the Irish Mobile Market
    • The Shift from Growth to Retention in the Irish Telecoms Market
    • Five Challenges that the IoT is facing
    • Why ComReg is Vital for a Successful Telecoms Industry in Ireland
    • Tesco Mobile passes 400,000 Customers and adds 4G
    • How our Mobile Providers are facilitating surging Data Traffic
    • Eight Industries that are being transformed by Sigfox
    • Vodafone Review: The Best Network in Ireland keeps getting Better
    • Why will 5G be faster than 4G?
    • Is Xavier Niel on the verge of shaking up the Irish Mobile Market with Eir
    • Eir overhauls its mobile plans, giving customers more data than ever
    • NB-IoT Explained: The Technology that Vodafone hopes will connect everything
    • The MVNO Flop: Why Ireland's MVNOs have failed to make an impact
    • Explained: Why Telecoms and Media Giants are Merging
    • The Power of Sigfox: Pioneering the IoT Revolution
    • Vodafone Ireland launches "V by Vodafone", bringing the Internet of Things to the masses
    • The IoT Revolution: Connecting Everything
    • The Unlimited Delusion: When Unlimited means Limited
    • The Best Mobile Plans for your Business
    • The Best Bill Pay Plans in Ireland
    • The Best Pay as you go Plans in Ireland
    • Was the Three-O2 Merger a Mistake?
    • The State of Irish Mobile Networks: Summer 2018
    • Vodafone killed Cherry Points: A Mistake?
    • Here's how 5G will transform Ireland
    • Three just stormed past Eir
    • An analysis of Ireland's big three Mobile Networks
    • How Cheap can our Mobile Plans Get?
    • Net Neutrality: More than the Internet is at stake
    • Here's why Vodafone's pay as you go plans are the best out there.
    • iD Mobile's Demise is hardly a surprise
    • The Battle for 5G Supremacy
    • Unlimited Data is only as good as the Network it's on.
  • Reviews
    • eir Mobile Review: Not the Network to choose in 2018
    • Invoxia GPS Tracker Review: Elegance boasts Phenomenal Battery Life
    • Three Review: The Best Value Network in Ireland
    • Sennheiser AMBEO Smart Headset Review:
    • Vodafone TV Review: Redefining what we think of TV
    • Vodafone Mobile Broadband Review: Connecting the Disconnected
    • 3Plus Review: The Best Loyalty Program Out There
    • 3 Sim Only Review: World-Class Value
    • Tesco Mobile Review: The Best network for the Frugal
    • Three Review: All you can Eat Buffering
    • Vodafone Review: The Network to Beat
    • Meteor Review: Excellence Exemplified
    • Should Virgin Media be your next Mobile Network?
    • Samsung Galaxy S8: The Pinnacle of Smartphone Advancement
    • Huawei P10: The Best phone people don't know about
    • Vodafone Smart Platinum 7.
    • Vodafone Smart Prime 7.